📚心得【怒月】｜《The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress 》 by Robert Heinlein, 1966
#月球城市 #獨立革命 #無政府主義
《怒月》是我在看完Andy Weir的《月球城市》後接著看的經典老作，但以現代觀點來看，許多設定看了會讓人直搖頭。
作品中的Luna被比喻做「澳洲」：一個新大陸，卻拿來做為流放犯人、農業之用。明明是花了極高成本建設的月球城市，觀光、高汙染重工業、製造業、研究機構卻不是月球的主要產業，丟了滿滿的罪犯上來，沒錯他們因為重力適應因素、沒辦法隨意跑回地球生活，但這樣只會讓罪犯有機會挾持月球設施與資源吧？
將整個城市的公共設施都交給一個AI控制也十分可疑(To make a mistake is human, but to really fuck things up, you need a computer connected to everything.)，更可疑的是這個AI有意識與人格卻只有主角知道，且出問題只有主角「修得好」，管理系統的工程師團隊也太混太天真 😅
第二個祕密建造的Mass Driver軌道在建設時，明明應該是不小規模的工程，即使地球方面沒辦法從軌道上看到建設過程，也能從大量耐熱與超導材料的物流發覺事情不對勁才對。
最終戰時也是，為何地球軍不從軌道轟炸就好？還很堅持要登陸，且部隊沒一個有準備，通通不適應月球重力，整個地球政府像是由嬰兒領導一般、天真到可怕，能不自己瓦解真是奇蹟。
月球上有氧、矽、鐵、鎂、鋁、鈣，若這些原料無法在原地作高經濟價值工業產品的加工，並很方便的直接將廢水、廢氣排至反正無人能生存、高輻射環境的月面，應該沒人會願意為了這些常見礦物在月球上投資，也不會有人願意從地球進口零組件去月球上組裝，只能作為觀光與研究重鎮，像Andy Weir的《Artemis》。
IMO總分：61分，即使被稱為經典作品，仍讓我覺得過於天真的中下作。
核心思想：★★★☆☆ 核心討論議題是否有趣*5
劇情細節：★★☆☆☆ 綜觀整體劇情的質與量*4
角色刻畫：★★☆☆☆ 角色群的必要性與深度*3
科學軟硬：★★★★★ 是否符合現實物理現象*3
結局滿意：★★★☆☆ 結局滿意度與有無餘韻*3
易讀程度：★★★★☆ 閱讀時章節是否難消化*2
#Lunar_City #Independence_Revolution #Anarchy
《The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress 》 is a classic I read after finishing Andy Weir's 《The Martian》, but from a modern perspective, many of its concepts feel outdated and questionable.
In the story, Luna is compared to Australia: a new frontier, yet used for exiling convicts and agriculture. Despite being an extremely costly lunar city to build, tourism, high-pollution industries, manufacturing, and research facilities aren't its main purposes. Instead, they send over criminals who can't easily return to Earth due to gravity adaptation issues. Yet, this setup only gives the criminals opportunities to seize control of lunar facilities and resources. Guess it isn't a good idea lol.
Having an AI manage the entire city's public infrastructure is already suspicious (quote, "To make a mistake is human, but to really mess things up, you need a computer connected to everything."), and it gets even weirder. This AI has consciousness and personality but only the main character knows about it. Plus, fixing the system only falls on the protagonist, while the engineering team overseeing it seems clueless and naive. Is this AHI in love with the protagonist? I think it only makes sense if that's the case.
Another thing that doesn't make sense to me is, construction of the second secretly-built mass driver track should have been a large-scale project. Even if Earth couldn't observe the construction from orbit, the massive shipments of heat-resistant and superconducting materials would raise some eyebrows.
During the final battle, it's baffling why Earth's military doesn't just bomb Luna from orbit. Instead, they insists on landing without any preparation, with troops totally unprepared for lunar gravity. The whole operation feels like it's led by infants — so naive it's unbelievable the Earth government doesn't collapse on its own.
With oxygen, silica, iron, magnesium, aluminum, and calcium available on the moon, if these raw materials can't be processed into high-value industrial products locally, and waste water and exhaust gas can just be dumped into the uninhabited, high-radiation lunar surface, no one would invest in building a city there just for those common minerals. To me, it would only make sense as a tourist and research hub, like in Andy Weir's 《Artemis》.
IMO Rating: 61. Despite being called a classic, it still feels too naive for me.
Core Theme: ★★★☆☆ (*5)
Plot Quality: ★★☆☆☆ (*4)
Character Development: ★★☆☆☆ (*3)
Science Validity: ★★★★★ (*3)
Ending Satisfaction: ★★★☆☆ (*3)
Readability: ★★★★☆ (*2)
留言
張貼留言